The best all-season tire…

…is one that hasn’t been invented yet. Until then, we still have the Nokian WR G2. These tires are sold in British Columbia exclusively by KalTire. I paid an arm and a leg for these tires but so far they’ve been totally worth it.

Nokian’s tire is classified as an “All-Weather” tire and bear the Severe Service Emblem endorsed by Transport Canada and the Rubber Association of Canada.

Forget the “All-Season” classification nonsense. All-Season tires generally have a “M+S” (for mud and snow) marking on the sidewall but really are just a compromise: they work just OK in a variety of conditions. This is why some people will use two sets of tires: performance tires for the summer (on nice alloy wheels), winter tires for the winter (usually on black steel wheels). You get dedicated tire performance for the weather conditions.

But what tire can I use all year that’ll give me good performance in snow? This is where the Nokian WR G2 excels. CanadianDriver has an article on the first generation WR. The WR G2, however, has a new asymmetrical tread pattern that offers the improved handling on wet and dry pavements.

nokian_wr_g2
 
 

nokian_wr_g2

Most all-season tires perform great in dry summer conditions, are “ok” in the wet, and really suck in the snow. My Mazda5’s OEM tires - Toyo A18 - are no exception.

Proxes A18
 
 

Proxes A18

I’m not the type to go swapping tires on my car. I drive a Mazda5, I’m not going to win any autocrosses anytime soon. And besides, our climate here is considered “temperate rainforest” climate. We get a lot of precipitation here. So I decided to get a tire that I can leave on year-round that shifts its characteristics more towards improved wet/snow performance. We’ve already had a few days now of snowfall (15cm of snow in my neighbourhood this morning) and so far, the WR G2’s don’t disappoint. Don’t get me wrong, the WR G2’s are still great in the dry, but when it comes to rain and snow, you really can’t put a price on safety.

No related posts. Try these:

4 Responses to “The best all-season tire…”

  1. [...] [...]

  2. Paul Durrant on May 27th, 2008 at 7:05 am

    Vince,

    How is the road noise with the Nokians? My wife has a 2007 Mazda5 Touring and I was considering these as replacements for her. The stock Toyos have become LOUD and that is her biggest complaint. The open design of the 5 really accentuates tire noise.

    I had Nokian Hakkas on my Subaru WRX for winter only use and loved them. I would love to hear your thoughts as a real-world owner driving the same vehicle. Thank you.

    Paul

  3. I actually found my stock Toyo A18 quieter compared to the WR G2’s. The drone might be a bit noticeable at first especially at highway speeds but my family and I have gotten used to it.

    The OEM tire size of the Toyo A18 is 205/50/17. However, my tire dealer couldn’t find that size on the WR G2. The closest size for the WR G2 is 215/45/17 (i.e. wider, lower profile).
    http://www.nokiantires.com/en/tire_wrg2.aspx?season=winter

    Despite the wider tire, these tires outperform the A18 in rain and snow. Also, 215/45 has a smaller circumference than 205/50. So your speedometer will read faster than normal and your mileage on your odometer will be read more than actual.

  4. Paul Durrant on May 28th, 2008 at 4:02 am

    Thanks for the reply. I guess that logic would dictate that with all of the additional siping on the Nokians that they would not be the quietest of tires at speed. Oh well, life is full of trade-offs. I appreciate your real world insight.

    Paul

Leave a Reply